home c.v. papers blog courses etc.  

P.D. Magnus

How to be a realist about natural kinds

An engagement with Laura-Franklin Hall's discussion of natural kinds, especially on the question of what counts as anti-realism.

Versions available

Abstract

Laura Franklin-Hall argues for a nuanced anti-realism about natural kinds. In the course of her argument, she considers the accounts offered by Richard Boyd and me to be alternative anti-realist views. But Boyd and I are both avowed realists about natural kinds. There is an important presupposition hidden in the way that Franklin-Hall poses the problem, namely that a real natural kind must be natural simpliciter. Boyd and I take naturalness to be a relation between a kind and a domain and, because we do not accept a presupposition of the question, are neither realists nor anti-realists in Franklin-Hall's sense. Nevertheless, there is another important sense in which domain-specificity is compatible with realism.

The first on-line draft of this paper was posted 8aug2014.

e-mail