Specialization: philosophy of science
Areas of research include underdetermination, scientific realism, and
natural kinds.
Teaching interests also include logic, history of modern philosophy, and
metaphysics.
Education
- Ph.D. in Philosophy. 2003. University of California, San Diego.
Underdetermination and the Claims of Science
committee: Paul Churchland (chair), Donald Rutherford, Nancy Cartwright,
Naomi Oreskes, Martin Sereno
- M.A. in Philosophy. 2000. UC San Diego.
- B.A. major in Philosophy and Physics, minor in Russian and Mathematics.
1996.
Texas Christian University; University Honors, summa cum laude.
Academic employment
- University at Albany, State University of New York: Philosophy, 2004– . As
associate professor since 2010.
- Center for Philosophy of Science, University of Pittsburgh: Visiting fellow, Fall
2010.
- Bowdoin College: Visiting assistant professor in Philosophy, 2003–2004.
- UC San Diego: Associate or teaching assistant in Philosophy for nine terms
between 1998 and 2003. Philosophy Department webmaster, 1998–2000.
- Editorial assistant for the journal Philosophy of Science. 1998–1999.
Publications
Books
Articles
- ‘No grist for Mill on natural kinds.’ Under review.
- with Heather Douglas. ‘Why novel prediction matters.’ Under review.
- ‘Historical individuals like Anas platyrhynchos and ‘Classical Gas” in Art
& Abstract Objects. Christy Mag Uidhir, ed. Oxford University Press.
Forthcoming.
- ‘Drakes, seadevils, and similarity fetishism.’ Biology&Philosophy, 26(6), 2011:
857–870. November 2011.
- ‘Miracles, trust, and ennui in Barnes’ Predictivism.’ Logos&Episteme, 2(1):
103–115. March 2011.
- with Christy Mag Uidhir. ‘Art concept pluralism.’ Metaphilosophy, 42(1–2):
83–97. January 2011.
- ‘Philosophy of science in the 21st century.’ In Russian, Istoriko-Philosophskii
Almanach, Moscow; third issue, 2010: 469–473. Forthcoming in English,
Metaphilosophy.
- ‘Inductions, red herrings, and the best explanation for the mixed record of
science.’ The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 61(4): 803–819.
December 2010.
- with Greg Frost-Arnold. ‘The Identical Rivals Response to underdetermination’
in New Waves in Philosophy of Science. P.D. Magnus and Jacob Busch, eds.
Palgrave Macmillan. 2010.
- ‘On trusting Wikipedia.’ Episteme. 6(1): 74–90. February 2009.
- ‘Demonstrative induction and the skeleton of inference.’ International Studies
in the Philosophy of Science. 22(3): 303–315. October 2008.
- ‘Early response to false claims in Wikipedia.’ First Monday. 13(9): September
2008.
- ‘Mag Uidhir on performance.’ British Journal of Aesthetics. 48(3): 338–345.
July 2008.
- ‘Reid’s defense of common sense.’ Philosophers’ Imprint, 8(3): 1–14. May 2008.
- with Lawrence Schell. ‘Is there an elephant in the room? Addressing rival
approaches to the interpretation of growth perturbations and small size.’
American Journal of Human Biology, 19(5): 606–614. September/October 2007.
- ‘Distributed cognition and the task of science.’ Social Studies of Science, 37(2):
297–310. April 2007.
- ‘What’s new about the New Induction?’ Synthese, 148(2): 295–301. January
2006.
- ‘Underdetermination of theories’ in The Philosophy of Science: An
Encyclopedia. Sahotra Sarkar and Jessica Pfeifer, eds. Routledge. 2005.
- ‘Background theories and total science.’ Philosophy of Science, 72(5):
1064–1075. December 2005.
- ‘Reckoning the shape of everything: Underdetermination and cosmotopology.’
British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 56(3): 541–557. September 2005.
- ‘Hormone research as an exemplar of underdetermination.’ Studies in History
and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 36(3): 559–567.
September 2005.
- ‘Peirce: Underdetermination, agnosticism, and related mistakes.’ Inquiry, 48(1):
26–37. February 2005.
- with Craig Callender, ‘Realist ennui and the base rate fallacy.’ Philosophy of
Science, 71(3): 320–338. July 2004.
- ‘The price of insisting that Quantum Mechanics is complete.’ British Journal
for the Philosophy of Science, 55(2): 257–267. June 2004.
- ‘Reid’s dilemma and the uses of pragmatism.’ Journal of Scottish Philosophy,
2(1): 69–72. March 2004.
- ‘Underdetermination and the Problem of Identical Rivals.’ Philosophy of
Science, 70(5): 1256–1264. December 2003.
- with Jonathan Cohen, ‘Williamson on knowledge and psychological
explanation.’ Philosophical Studies, 116(1): 37–52. October 2003.
- ‘Success, truth, and the Galilean Strategy.’ British Journal for the Philosophy
of Science, 54(3): 465–474. September 2003.
- with Michael Kalichman, education resources for the Responsible Conduct of
Research Education Consortium. September 2002. Reprinted in the University
of Arizona’s Program in Research Integrity Education PRIE Newsletter, 6(6):
June 2006 through 7(4): April 2007.
Presentations
- ‘Drakes, seadevils, and similarity fetishism.’ Presented at Metaphysics & the
Philosophy of Science at the University of Toronto (May 2011).
- ‘Nine planets, fine planets — or eight planets, great planets?’ Invited
presentation to the philosophy department at the City College of New York
(November 2010).
- ‘Miracles, trust, and ennui in Barnes’ Predictivism.’ Part of a book symposium
at the Philosophy of Science Association biennial meeting in Montreal, Quebec
(November 2010).
- ‘What to say about natural kinds.’ Lunchtime talk at the Center for Philosophy
of Science, University of Pittsburgh (October 2010).
- ‘Ubiquity and relativity of natural kinds.’ Invited presentation to the Cornell
University Philosophy Department (May 2010).
- ‘The Identical Rivals Response to underdetermination.’ Invited presentation,
Underdetermination in Science workshop, Center for Philosophy of Science,
University of Pittsburgh (March 2009).
- ‘Philosophy of science in the 21st century.’ Presented at a telematic symposium
on developments in philosophy, held between UAlbany and Moscow State
University (February 2009).
- ‘Theory concept pluralism.’ Presented to the University of Nevada Las Vegas
philosophy department (February 2009).
- ‘Philosophy and Wikipedia.’ Presented to the UAlbany philosophy department
(December 2008).
- ‘What SPECIES can teach us about THEORY.’ Presented to the Creighton
Club New York State Philosophical Association and published in conference
proceedings (November 2007).
- ‘The skeleton of inference.’ Invited presentation to the Southern Methodist
University philosophy department (March 2007).
- ‘Epistemology and the Wikipedia.’ Presented at the North American Computing
and Philosophy Conference in Troy, New York (August 2006).
- ‘Eliminating induction.’ Presented at the Society for Exact Philosophy annual
meeting in La Jolla, California (May 2006).
- ‘Tom Reid meets Tom Bayes: skepticism, dogmatism and common sense.’
Presented at Hume and His Critics, a conference on the Scottish Enlightenment
at Baylor University (April 2005).
- ‘Background theories and total science.’ Presented at the Philosophy of Science
Association biennial meeting in Austin, Texas (November 2004).
- ‘The value of philosophy.’ Presented at the Maine Philosophical Institute (May
2004).
- ‘The promise and perils of science as distributed cognition.’ Presented to the
UC San Diego Experimental Philosophy Lab (January 2004).
- ‘Williamson on knowledge and psychological explanation.’ Presented at the
Inland Northwest Philosophy Conference (May 2003).
- ‘Science, underdetermination, and the structure of space.’ Presented under
various titles as a colloquium at UC San Diego (January 2003), as an invited
talk to the Bowdoin College philosophy department (April 2003), and as an
invited talk to the UAlbany philosophy department (January 2004).
- ‘Underdetermination and aspirations of certainty.’ Presented to the UC San
Diego History of Philosophy Roundtable (June 2002).
- ‘Underdetermination and the Problem of Identical Rivals.’ Presented at the
Southern California Philosophy Conference at UC Irvine (October 2001) and at
the Philosophy of Science Association biennial meeting in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
(November 2002).
- ‘Reliability on the crowded net: Finding the truth in a web of deceit.’ Presented
at MacHack and published in conference proceedings (June 2001).
- ‘Underdetermination and the inference against value freedom.’ Presented at
Value-Free Science: Ideal or Illusion?, a conference sponsored by the Ethics
Center at the University of Alabama, Birmingham (February 2001).
- ‘Reality, sex, and cyberspace: an exercise in philosophy of technology.’ Presented
at MacHack in Detroit, Michigan and published in conference proceedings (June
2000).
- ‘The logic of normative structure.’ Presented at Philosophy and the Social
Sciences, a graduate student conference at the University of Texas, Austin
(March 2000).
Academic Awards and Fellowships
- Visiting Fellowship at the Center for Philosophy of Science, Pittsburgh (Fall
2010)
- UAlbany, College of Arts and Sciences Dean’s Award for Excellence in Teaching
(2009)
- National Science Foundation Graduate Fellowship (1996–2001)
- A. Campbell Garnet Memorial Award for a Philosophical Essay (1996)
- TCU Senior Scholar in Philosophy, Senior Scholar in Physics (1996)
- Phi Beta Kappa: elected (1995), ΦBK Senior Scholar (1996)
- Sigma Xi Essay Award (1995)
Teaching
Courses taught
Introductory undergraduate courses
- Introduction to logic; sentential and first-order logic
- Understanding science; an introduction to philosophy of science and science
studies
Upper-division undergraduate courses
- History of modern philosophy; Descartes to Kant
- American philosophy; the transcendentalist and pragmatist traditions
- Existentialism
- Scientific revolutions; accounts of science before and after Kuhn
Lecture courses for graduate students and advanced undergraduates
- Metaphysics
- Theory of knowledge
- Philosophy of science
Graduate seminars
- Causality and determinism
- Underdetermination of theory
- Realism and natural kinds
Webpages for all courses are at http://www.fecundity.com/courses
Dissertation and thesis advisement
- Member, Ph.D. committee for Tom Fowler. In progress.
- Member, Ph.D. committee for Kevin Olbrys. In progress.
- Member, Ph.D. committee for Kimberley Van Orman. In progress.
- Member, Ph.D. committee for Juliette Stevens. Mental Causation: A
Nonreductivist Perspective. Summer 2008.
- Advisor, undergraduate honors thesis for Brett Bustamante. Applied Humor
Theory. Spring 2008.
- Chair, Ph.D. committee for John Styles. Empirically Grounded Metaphors in
Science. Spring 2008.
- Examiner in History for Dan Spanjer. Spring 2007.
Academic service
- UAlbany Philosophy Department: Undergraduate studies committee (2004–6,
2007–11) Director of undergraduate studies (2005–6, 2007–10) Department
webmaster (2004– ) Program review and assessment (2006– ) Hiring committee
(2005–6, 2006–7) Colloquium committee (2005–6) Graduate studies committee
(2004–5,2011–2)
- UAlbany Council on Research (2007–08) including the benevolent award, faculty
research award, conflict of interest subcommittees
- Chair and co-organizer, first annual Graduate Mini-Conference, UC San Diego
Philosophy (April 2003)
- MacHack papers committee (2001, 2002)
- Article referee for journals including The American Journal of Bioethics, The
British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, Erkenntnis, Inquiry, International
Studies in the Philosophy of Science, Philosophy and Phenomenological
Research, Philosophy of Science, The Polish Journal of Philosophy, Studies in
History and Philosophy of Science, and Synthese.
- Book referee for McGraw-Hill and Palgrave Macmillan.